What is it like to negotiate with Russian representatives regarding the war in the region?
This question has generated widespread interest following multiple recent rounds of ceasefire talks, which have so far appeared to produce minimal fruit four years after the full-scale military offensive.
Another round of American-facilitated negotiations is likely to occur in the Swiss city later this week. In preparation, an important member of Ukrainian President Zelensky's delegation, Sergiy Kyslytsya, who has been involved in recent military-to-military discussions, has provided his perspective.
As stated by Kyslytsya, these dealings are professional and generally free of the sort of ideological and rhetorical posturing seen in other forums by Moscow.
"The military possess a better understanding of the realities in the battlefield," he remarked in a meeting on Monday morning.
"It's another thing if they [the Russians] are capable, or not, of relaying information accurately…without altering or distorting the facts," he continued.
It is far from an simple thing to try to halt a war. The reality of the front line in the Donbas region - where tens of thousands of unmanned aerial vehicles patrol and strike over a vast so-called "contested area" separating the opposing forces, while two hundred thousand local residents still reside in the "heavily fortified" cities of the Donbas - renders the practical process of separation highly complex.
"You have to have a precise set of rules and protocols," Kyslytsya explained, "along with a method to confirm and oversee."
The Involvement of International Parties
A great deal of these preparations, he said, is finished, thanks in part to the close involvement of American officials, including a senior NATO commander and a high-ranking Army official.
It's obviously against Ukraine's benefit to criticise envoys of the American government, but when Kyslytsya praises the US delegation for its efforts, he comes across as sincere.
"We must credit the US side for their dedication and their patience," he says, "because they sit in the sessions continuously. They not only observe…they put questions and they listen to our answers."
The negotiator was equally complimentary about the roles of the former president's adviser, whom he described as "experienced", and billionaire mediator the special representative, whom he described as "a much wiser person than the simplified image you see in the media".
The United States, Kyslytsya said, will undertake a key role in monitoring any future ceasefire, with resources including satellite and other types of high-tech surveillance.
"It is necessary to have someone who will play the role of an arbitrator, for the reason that if there is a breach there must be a neutral actor that is solid [and] respected."
Past and Current Monitoring Challenges
During an eight-year period before Russia's full-scale invasion in recent years, this monitoring role was played by the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe - a body whose restricted resources and lack of enforcement mechanisms rendered it mostly unable of preventing an escalation.
"That was quite an achievement [for them] simply to operate two UAVs flying above the area," Kyslytsya said. "It resembles the stone age era in contrast with what we are dealing with now."
By contrast, latest analyses suggest that as many as twelve thousand drones are active above the single city of a frontline city at any given moment.
A Personal Perspective on Confronting the Adversary
When asked how he managed to negotiate directly from emissaries representing a leader in the Kremlin who has been willing to expend more than a million of his own men to conquer its neighbor, the diplomat, also a former UN ambassador, provided his response.
He told that he'd had years of practice.
"I saw much worse. I served a five-year term in at the UN, three of them before the major war. I regularly had to sit in the room with the enemy on a regular basis."
A particular night is seared in his recollection: the eve of the invasion.
During an emergency UN Security Council meeting, convened to discuss the urgent crisis in the country, the diplomat got word that his homeland was under attack.
At the same time, far away to the eastward in Kyiv, the first far-off explosions signaled as Russia's all-out assault on Ukraine began.
During moments of agonising tension, Kyslytsya tried to persuade his Russian counterpart, Vassily Nebenzia, to call his boss, Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, to seek guarantees that Moscow's troops would not cross the border.
"I have stated everything I know now," Nebenzia replied, as recalled by Kyslytsya. "I will not disturb the minister at this hour."
Everyone's lives were transformed at that moment. Kyslytsya remained at the UN for an additional period before returning to Kyiv.
The Path Forward
Should the negotiating teams reconvene in Geneva on Thursday, he will participate, still thrashing out the contours and mechanics of a ceasefire but waiting continuously for the most important element of the puzzle to fall into place.
"Hostilities could be ended by simply a single order of an individual to his top general," he stated.
"But apparently, the Russian president [Vladimir Putin] is not up to stopping the war for the time being."